I'm standing on my soapbox today for my slice of life. This topic has been eating at me for a while now and I couldn't help but write about it. It just came out.
For more slice of life stories, be sure to visit Two Writing Teachers.
I feel it. I feel it
building this year like a pressure cooker.
I hear it in comments from my colleagues. I see it on the faces of fellow teachers I
pass in the hallway. I can’t get away
from the feeling of content and deadlines being shoved down my throat. I can’t get away from the notions of “we have
to get the kids to do things faster/sooner/better.”
Logically, I understand it.
I know that things change at the top and there is a trickle down. I know that when you sit at the bottom of the
educational mountain, the push down is going to stop there. Unfortunately, it
seems that the trickle down has become more of a gushing, roaring river as it
has cut a path down the mountain and found the way to my kindergarten doorstep.
While I may know how this works LOGICALLY, I feel very
differently in my heart. My heart knows
that my students are only approximately 60 months old. My heart knows that I can push the thinking
of my students only so far, and more than that is useless. My heart knows, as a teacher, I am should meet
my students where they are as an individual and then guide them toward the next
step. However, the next step should not
be expected to be a huge LEAP.
It seems the expectation has changed. Now I am expected to meet the children where
they are and then SHOVE them toward where they “should” be. It’s a game of tag gone awry…ready or not
here it comes!
What happened to learning through play? What happened to looking for the next step
and guiding the child to discovery? What
happened to learning about child development and then using that knowledge to
help determine what the child is ready for next? When did “they,” whoever the decision-makers are,
learn about what is best practice for teaching?
When did “they” learn about the developmental stages that a child grows
through? Most importantly, when did
“they” learn what is best for children?
Learning and growing is like planting a seed. A child is a seed that we plant in our kinder
garden. We give that seed the sunshine,
water and nourishment that is needed for growth to happen but it will ONLY
happen on the seed’s own timetable.
There is no pushing the agenda for a seed. I cannot force a seed to sprout without light
and water and nourishing soil any more than I can force a child to learn
something the brain is not ready to accept.
I can use all the best techniques and spend time one-on-one with that
child and put the best materials in the hands of the child, but if that child
is not ready to take on the learning, it’s not going to happen.
This group of people who are the “they” are making decisions
about things that they know nothing about.
I would like the opportunity to ask them to consider a few things. When you need brain surgery, do you ask your
neighbor to do it for you? When you have
a tooth that is painful, do you pull it out yourself? Of course not! We call upon the experts.
Why are “they” not calling upon the experts to make
educational decisions? When did it
become logical and appropriate to ask lawyers or businessmen to determine what should
be taught in a classroom? Where is the professional respect for teachers? I wonder what would happen if “they” went to
the emergency room only to find out that their so-called doctor was really a plumber
or a computer programmer?
I can only imagine the destruction that this push for more and better and faster is causing in kindergarten. I see the effects on students who have given up in middle school, on students who have decided that reading and learning are stupid. Thank you for speaking out. If we raise our voices together, maybe we can stop the madness.
ReplyDeleteWell said. We teachers all need to join in saying it.
ReplyDeleteI wish "they" could read your post. Oh, that's right they were able to learn at the rate appropriate for them. When will the madness stop?
ReplyDeleteI know, in my heart, that I rely on those teachers I work with to know what is best for "their" students. They know them well, and do what is best for them. I'm so sorry that you feel so pressed about this, Robin. I wish I could help in some way, but here's a big hug for you, for telling it exactly how it is! I hear so many saying this!
ReplyDeleteMaybe next time "they" need assistance in an emergency room, only a teacher is available to assist them. Oh wait, teachers are not that selfish; a teacher would go out of her way to find a doctor!
ReplyDeletePerfectly stated. Perfectly right. :-(
ReplyDelete